Controversial Bishop Accused of Covering up Sexual Abuse Allegations in His Diocese prompts Pope Francis’ ‘Fiducia Supplicans’ a Failure of Biblical Proportions

The appointment of Monsignor Victor Manuel Fernández as the head of the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, also known as the Holy Office, by Pope Francis has raised significant concerns among Catholics. The Dicastery, founded to defend the Catholic Church from heresy, has the important responsibility of promoting and defending Catholic doctrine. However, Fernández, who was appointed by Pope Francis, is a controversial figure with a history that has generated significant pushback. His appointment has garnered criticism from both within and outside the Church. Fernández is known for his theological work and authorship of over 300 works, including the 1995 book “Heal me with your mouth: The art of kissing”. The book has led to concerns about his adherence to the orthodoxy of the Catholic Church. The controversy surrounding Fernández’s appointment has brought the suitability of his role into question.

Pope Francis’s decision to appoint Fernández has been met with dismay and protest among conservative Catholics. There are concerns about Fernández’s handling of cases involving the sexual abuse of children and his theological work, particularly his failure to believe victims who accused a priest in his archdiocese of sexual abuse. Critics have questioned Fernández’s suitability for such a high position in the Church, given these controversies.

The reactions to Fernández’s appointment have been mixed. While some liberal dioceses in western Europe have embraced the decision, many others, especially in the global south, have expressed hostility and refusal to implement the declaration. The unfolding events have raised doubts about Pope Francis’s leadership and decision-making. The response to Fernández’s appointment reflects the deep divisions within the Catholic Church, with many questioning the direction in which Pope Francis is taking the Church.

Fernández has attempted to address the concerns, emphasizing that there is no change in the doctrine on marriage – male-female, exclusive, indissoluble, and naturally open to the generation of new life. However, his reassurances have not fully addressed the doubts and criticisms surrounding his appointment. Many within the Church remain skeptical about whether his controversial background and theological work are compatible with his new role.

The controversy surrounding Fernández’s appointment represents a significant challenge for Pope Francis’s leadership. The criticisms and pushback from within the Church and beyond have cast doubt on his decision-making and the direction in which he is taking the Church. The appointment of Fernández as the head of the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith has become a focal point for the deep divisions within the Catholic Church and has raised questions about the future of the Church under Pope Francis’s leadership.


Hot News