San Francisco’s African American Reparations Advisory Committee suggested handing out $5 million plus other benefits to eligible black residents. The group asked for $2 million to keep their operations up and running, but the city did not grant their request.
Governor Kathy Hochul of New York followed suit and signed a bill to create a reparations commission, despite the failed attempt in California. The commission will use taxpayer money to investigate reparations for descendants of slaves.
Reverend Al Sharpton approved of the reparations commission, believing it could “heal the wounds.” However, some argue that big promises in the name of helping do not make the situation any better.
Hochul stated that New York’s history with slavery cannot be ignored, and the state has benefitted from the institution of slavery. She urged New Yorkers to confront this part of their past and embrace the conversation about reparations.
The nine-member commission has one year to deliver a report with recommendations, which could include monetary compensation. However, the potential cost to taxpayers is a concern, especially as New York faces a $4.3 billion deficit.
Senate Republican Leader Rob Ortt pointed out the sacrifices made to end slavery in the Civil War. He stressed that reparations would come at an astronomical cost to city residents.
The influx of nearly 100,000 illegal immigrants into New York City this year has led to Mayor Eric Adams seeking financial assistance from President Joe Biden. It’s worth noting that other states, such as Massachusetts and New Jersey, are also considering conducting reparation studies.
In California, a proposed payout program would cost the state over $1.2 million per black resident. All of these financial commitments come at a time when both California and New York are facing budget deficits and fiscal challenges.
Amid the discussions of reparations and the provision of benefits to illegal immigrants, questions arise about the resources available for residents who do not have similar government support. This situation is particularly concerning for those living in Democratic states dealing with historical grievances.
The topic of reparations and the allocation of funds has raised questions about the financial priorities of state governments, especially in light of budget deficits and other pressing needs.
Ultimately, the discussions around reparations and the use of public funds continue to raise concerns about the financial stability of states, as well as the impact on taxpayers and residents.
